• Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Major Foodie

Fine Dining Honestly Reviewed

  • About Me
  • Most Recent
  • Highest Rated
  • Restaurant Map
  • Locations
    • London
      • City
      • East
      • East Central
      • Mayfair & Central West
      • North Central
      • Southbank
      • South East
      • South West
      • West End
    • Rest of UK
      • Central England
      • Jersey
      • North England
      • Northern Ireland
      • South East England
      • South England
      • South West England
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • Rest of World
      • Europe
        • Croatia
        • Denmark
        • France
        • Germany
        • Ireland
        • Italy
        • Malta
        • Norway
        • Portugal
        • Spain
        • Turkey
      • Asia
        • Bali
        • China
          • Beijing
          • Hangzhou
          • Hong Kong
          • Macau
          • Shanghai
        • Japan
          • Kobe
          • Kyoto
          • Tokyo
        • Singapore
        • Thailand
          • Bangkok
          • Phuket
          • Koh Pha Ngan
          • Koh Samui
      • Dubai
      • America
        • Chicago
        • Las Vegas
        • Napa Valley
        • Nashville
        • New York
        • Washington DC
      • Australia
  • Cuisine
    • African
    • American
    • Asian
    • British Modern
    • British Traditional
    • Chinese
    • Classic
    • Creative
    • Croatian
    • French
    • Indian
    • Italian
    • Japanese
    • Meats and Grills
    • Mediterranean
    • Modern
    • Nordic
    • Peruvian
    • Portuguese
    • Regional / Country
    • Tempura
    • Turkish
    • Seafood
    • Spanish
    • Sushi
    • Vegetarian
  • Best For
    • Atmosphere
    • Breakfast
    • Brunch
    • Burgers
    • Counter / Bar Dining
    • Celebrations
    • Fish & Chips
    • Michelin Starred Pubs
    • Pizza
    • Pre-Theatre
    • Private Dining
    • Romantic
    • Set Menu Under £25
    • Sunday Roast
    • Top Major Foodie Rating (90%+)
    • Value Set Menu
    • Vegetarian
    • View
  • Filter Search
  • Blog

Number One at The Balmoral Hotel (Edinburgh)

20th January 2017 by Richard Bagnold Leave a Comment

Detached restaurant to Balmoral Hotel, Edinburgh displaying quality cooking and elegant dishes

With its main entrance directly accesible from Princes Street you would be forgiven Number One was separate to the Balmoral hotel.  However, it most definitely is a part of the hotel and is suitably laid out to remind guests they are in a flagship hotel.  This was a highly enjoyable tasting menu with a high level of design from intricate canapes and petit fours to the bread selection and I had one of the best dishes in a long time via their signature cold-smoked salmon dish which was frankly superb.  Serving as an evening, romantic treat as probably its main forte (with no natural light being underground) I believe this could be enhanced even more with a small tweak to their music selection and I would also see this restaurant working for celebration events well.

Read full review

This was a slick menu, no question.  The canapes that arrived of cheese and welsh rarebit gougères were a good concept and crunchy, but somehow I wanted more moisture.  The liver parfait with delicately thin shell canape left me grinning from ear to ear.  The amuse bouche of Scottish lobster with orange hollondaise was a brilliant varient for the hollondaise but I found I didn’t need the mandarin slice as big as this dominated and drowned the rest of the small elements on the plate for me.

The salmon: worthy of a paragraph in its own right.  For one, this was the best dish I had on this weekend that saw me visiting all four Michelin starred restuarants in Edinburgh and for another, it is one of the best dishes I have had full stop.  The salmon is cold-smoked through clever kitchen equipment as the smoke from the woodchips is passed through laboratory kit in order to bring down its temperature.  The effect this has on the salmon is to give it its smokey flavour but reduce the overall oilyness, leaving a protein rich and flavoursome quality without overloading on the fat content.  This, combined with the luxuriously rich quail’s egg gave the dish it sumptuous quailty with perfect balance of salt from the caviar and cod roe and a beautiful judgement of the lemon curd providing sweetness and just enough sharp from the apple matchsticks.  The latter components helped to bring this dish together completely.  The final layer of small chicken skin crisps were a wonderful component to have and these raised the overall flavour to the stratosphere and it really was an utterly superb dish as a result.  I was told that it had taken three years of refinement to get this dish to where it is and my good fortune to catch it its current guise.

The beetroot was very fresh but could done with a bit more cheese or some pickle to make less flat as it simply seemed to need something else, although there was lovely beetroot ice cream to go with this.  The halibut with squid pasta and creamed sauce beneath was refined but did not make me sing truth be told.  However, the fillet of beef, was luxury to the core – perfect jus, beautifully tasty and tender beef, fried seaweed element, and potato in support was excellent.  Pretty darned happy by this stage.

The pre-dessert of kohlrabi custard was quite citric but well designed and had a lovely crunch of the almond slices with light texture of the custard as well.  The almagnac ice cream was not really my bag but the soufflé was great with its supporting banana component serving as a very pleasing add on as opposed to the usual blob of ice cream.  There was no question with the skill here, but I had just too much sharpness for this dessert for me.  The petit fours of rhubarb and custard stretched sugar with sherbert produced childhood memories and was perfectly light enough at the same time.  The chocolate disc was decadent and these rounded off a job very well done by Number One.

Overall I was very pleased with this meal and it was clear that the staff were very much behind the concept of wanting the exprience to be a higher grade of one for the diner.  Numerous satisfaction bells were ringing for the food on this menu and the effort was also clear as a bell.  A couple of things only that I didn’t agree with but overall this was a splendid meal, worthy of being a stamp in the city to do for an occasion of sorts.

Food Grade: 82%

Front Entrance
Tatsing menu – 20 Jan 17
Canapés presentation
Canapés
Bread selection
Amuse bouche
Salmon hidden beneath smoked cloche
Salmon with cod roe, lemon curd, apple matchsticks and chicken skin
Beetroot
Halibut
Accompanying red
Fillet of beef
Beef close up
Kohlrabi custard pre-dessert
Caramel soufflé
Petit fours selection
Petit fours choices
The dinner bill for 1

Location

Leave a Review of this Restaurant Cancel reply

  • Food Rating - 82%
    82

Summary

Slick service.
Some outstanding dishes.
Careful design.

Background music.
Seriousness.

Restaurant Details

Michelin Stars:

Cuisine: Modern

Address: Balmoral Hotel, 1 Princes St, Edinburgh EH2 2EQ

Website: Number One at The Balmoral Hotel (Edinburgh)

Telephone: +44 (0)131 557 6727

Recent Visit – 1 Star

L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon Saint-Germain (Paris)

30th May 2025

Recent Visit – 2 Stars

Brooklands by Claude Bosi (Hyde Park)

16th May 2024

Recent Visit – 3 Stars

Frantzén (Stockholm)

6th June 2025

Recent Visit – Not Starred but Recommended

Dishoom (Covent Garden)

5th November 2022

Food Consultancy

Concierge Services

Concierge food-themed experience

Concierge day out experience

Concierge tea experience

About Me

meMy hobby-turned-passion began to evolve during my assignments to London where I was fortunate enough to be able to explore all the Michelin starred restaurants in my spare time and as a result, I gradually built up a catalogue of all these venues.

Recent Additions

  • Frantzén (Stockholm) 6th June 2025
  • L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon Saint-Germain (Paris) 30th May 2025
  • Kioku (Raffles at The Old War Office) 8th May 2025

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign up to be notified whenever a new review is posted.

Read our privacy policy here.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy (UK)

Copyright © 2025 · swank WordPress Theme By, PDCD

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}