• Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Major Foodie

Fine Dining Honestly Reviewed

  • About Me
  • Most Recent
  • Highest Rated
  • Restaurant Map
  • Locations
    • London
      • City
      • East
      • East Central
      • Mayfair & Central West
      • North Central
      • Southbank
      • South East
      • South West
      • West End
    • Rest of UK
      • Central England
      • Jersey
      • North England
      • Northern Ireland
      • South East England
      • South England
      • South West England
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • Rest of World
      • Europe
        • Croatia
        • Denmark
        • France
        • Germany
        • Ireland
        • Italy
        • Malta
        • Norway
        • Portugal
        • Spain
        • Turkey
      • Asia
        • Bali
        • China
          • Beijing
          • Hangzhou
          • Hong Kong
          • Macau
          • Shanghai
        • Japan
          • Kobe
          • Kyoto
          • Tokyo
        • Singapore
        • Thailand
          • Bangkok
          • Phuket
          • Koh Pha Ngan
          • Koh Samui
      • Dubai
      • America
        • Chicago
        • Las Vegas
        • Napa Valley
        • Nashville
        • New York
        • Washington DC
      • Australia
  • Cuisine
    • African
    • American
    • Asian
    • British Modern
    • British Traditional
    • Chinese
    • Classic
    • Creative
    • Croatian
    • French
    • Indian
    • Italian
    • Japanese
    • Meats and Grills
    • Mediterranean
    • Modern
    • Nordic
    • Peruvian
    • Portuguese
    • Regional / Country
    • Tempura
    • Turkish
    • Seafood
    • Spanish
    • Sushi
    • Vegetarian
  • Best For
    • Atmosphere
    • Breakfast
    • Brunch
    • Burgers
    • Counter / Bar Dining
    • Celebrations
    • Fish & Chips
    • Michelin Starred Pubs
    • Pizza
    • Pre-Theatre
    • Private Dining
    • Romantic
    • Set Menu Under £25
    • Sunday Roast
    • Top Major Foodie Rating (90%+)
    • Value Set Menu
    • Vegetarian
    • View
  • Filter Search
  • Blog

The Punch Bowl (Crosthwaite)

2nd July 2016 by Richard Bagnold Leave a Comment

Gastropub and Inn with charming decor, located within the Lake District serving hearty food  

  • 2nd July 2016
  • 18th July 2015

I am now not a stranger to The Punch Bowl in Crosthwaite however, this was a special visit in the circumstances it was and the fact that this meal was followed by a stay over at the Inn itself.  The food on this occasion included old classics such as the cheese soufflé and the sirloin steak with wonderful garlic butter as the sauce, which was actually a welcome change from my usual vat of béarnaise sauce to accompany any steak that I have.

Read full review

The black pudding with egg and chutney was very pleasant and even though the pork crackling ‘straw’ was too hard in places to enjoy, it was well done and the presentation of the potato rösti with celeriac and apple and slow cooked egg was bordering on 1 Michelin starred quality.  The steak tartare was also prepared with a slow cooked egg which I thought was a very good touch as well and although a touch more gherkin, capers and shallots to filet steak seemed to be in the mix, I still enjoyed the overall result a lot.

The lovely touch with the chips here was the fact that they are cooked in beef dripping as a pleasant change for a hint of a more savoury flavour and the vanilla Panna cotta with honeycomb was a belter of a dessert – perfect consistency with the Panna cotta and lovely elements coming together to boost the interest of a classic.

It’s worth mentioning as well that the rooms here are utterly delightful.  It doesn’t affect the food grade given, however, ever since seeing this pub for the first time years ago, I have always wanted to stay.  I can now confirm that the gorgeously deep bath, rain shower, goose down pillows and wonderful grade mattresses and general rustic luxury design in the rooms here added to a superb stay with very good service.

Food Grade: 78%

Mussels
Black pudding and hen’s egg
Scallop
Cheese souffle
Sirloin and onion rings
Potato Rösti with celeriac
Steak tartare
Beff dripping cooked chips
Panna cotta

I have been here twice before; once for a special evening Birthday meal and the other for a lovely lunch and this third occasion was for an early dinner which simply did not dissapoint in any way.  The signature cheese soufflé was in full, cooked force on this occasion with its very creamy and lovely Lancashire cheese and all other dishes were very well done.  I was very impressed with the presentation too which, frankly wouldn’t have been out of place in many 1 Michelin starred venues I have eaten in and the supporting Rioja was nice and light and paired up very well with all our dishes.

Read full review

The style and care taken over the design of the food was obvious and flavours wise, it was all quite impressive as well, no question.  The highlights for me were the croquette bbq pork with apple gel and the almond ice cream, the latter really being superb, cutting through the zingy strawberry soufflé nicely and a treat on its own.

This is frankly one of the nicest and  most picturesque gatro pubs I have been to in the whole of the UK and for all round quality I think you will be hard pressed to find many other places much better.  It is also a B & B and frankly its charm makes me wish to be able to have the excuse to stay over one day simply to enjoy it on that count alone.  A true gem in Cumbria.

Food Grade: 78%

The Punch Bowl entrance
The Punch Bowl outdoor garden
Punch Bowl interior
Facts on where ingredients are sourced
Focaccia and grain breads
Scallops
Croquette of BBQ pork
Cheese soufflé
Pork main
Vegetable tagliatelli
Dauphinoise potato, tripple cooked chips and sauce bearnaise
Duck breast main
Caramel cheese cake with honeycomb
Strawberry soufflé with almond ice cream
Crème brulée

Location

Leave a Review of this Restaurant Cancel reply

  • Food Rating - 78%
    78

Summary

Beautiful setting.
Charming interior.
Homely service and food.

Designated driver required.

Restaurant Details

Michelin Stars: N/A

Cuisine: British

Address: Crosthwaite, Lyth Valley, Cumbria LA8 8HR

Website: The Punch Bowl (Crosthwaite)

Telephone: +44 15395 68237

Recent Visit – 1 Star

Mikla (Istanbul)

8th March 2025

Recent Visit – 2 Stars

Brooklands by Claude Bosi (Hyde Park)

16th May 2024

Recent Visit – 3 Stars

L’Assiette Champenoise (Reims)

22nd June 2023

Recent Visit – Not Starred but Recommended

Dishoom (Covent Garden)

5th November 2022

Food Consultancy

Concierge Services

Concierge food-themed experience

Concierge day out experience

Concierge tea experience

About Me

meMy hobby-turned-passion began to evolve during my assignments to London where I was fortunate enough to be able to explore all the Michelin starred restaurants in my spare time and as a result, I gradually built up a catalogue of all these venues.

Recent Additions

  • Kioku Bar (Raffles at The OWO) 2nd May 2025
  • Bleecker Burger (Bloomberg Arcade) 1st May 2025
  • Mikla (Istanbul) 8th March 2025

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign up to be notified whenever a new review is posted.

Read our privacy policy here.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy (UK)

Copyright © 2025 · swank WordPress Theme By, PDCD